Bayer's victory in its first court
battle over anti-cholesterol drug Baycol has sparked a sharp relief rally in
its shares and bonds as fears that liabilities might reach $10 billion
recede.
Industry analysts said on Wednesday a total payout of around $2 billion was
more likely, partially lifting the fog on an issue that has hampered Bayer's
efforts to find a partner for the sub-scale drugs business.
"The indirect effect of the judgement is that Bayer's management can now
concentrate better on finding a partner for its pharmaceutical business,"
said Christian Faitz, analyst at Julius Baer.
A jury in Texas ruled on Tuesday that Bayer was not liable for injuries an
elderly man claimed were caused by the recalled drug in the first of 8,400
lawsuits facing the German drugmaker.
The Leverkusen-based group has been seeking a partner for its beleaguered
pharmaceuticals unit for months without success and indicated last week that
it may have decided to wind down the search and concentrate on trying to
strengthen the business.
If confirmed, that is likely to disappoint investors who believe Bayer lacks
the means to give the business critical mass in a consolidating global
pharmaceuticals industry.
Its shares, which surged 40 percent late on Tuesday in reaction to the news,
slipped five percent to 13.58 euros, underperforming a stronger German DAX
index "It is a technical reaction after yesterday's massive rally, people
are now trying to make some profits," said a senior trader at major German
bank.
The stock has underperformed the DAX by 22 percent in 2003.
Analysts said the company still faced legal uncertainties, but the victory
in Texas -- a jurisdiction with a reputation for favouring plaintiffs --
indicated it should avoid the worst-case scenario of mammoth damages.
"The market was expecting at least six billion in claims and now that
appears to be down to two billion," said Stephan Thomas, a fund manager at
Frankfurt Trust.
"The market sees fair value for the shares at 16-18 euros... but I expect a
lot of volatility in the shares," he added.
More than 100 deaths have been linked to Baycol, which can cause a severe
muscle disorder called rhabdomyolosis. The medicine, known as Lipobay
outside the United States, was withdrawn from the market in 2001.
Fears that massive damages would trigger a cut in credit ratings hung over
Bayer's debt recently and its bonds rose sharply, with the six percent bond
due April 2012 bid 4.5 points higher at 98.6 percent of face value at 1445
GMT.
INSURANCE COVER
Although Bayer has product liability insurance, it admitted last week that
Baycol charges could exceed its cover if plaintiffs "substantially prevail".
However, Schroder Salomon Smith Barney analysts think it is now likely that
the vast bulk of settlements relating to Baycol will be settled by
insurance.
Bayer has already settled claims with some 500 patients who took Baycol for
a total of about $150 million, giving analysts some yardstick by which to
judge future payments.
"If Bayer continues to pay out around 280,000 euros per patient, it works
out to 2.3 billion euros ($2.44 billion)," said Bayerische Landesbank
analyst Michael Butscher.
Merrill Lynch analyst James Knight noted the actual figure could still vary
significantly, with the total turning out lower if it transpires Bayer has
settled the most severe cases first.
Alternatively, the figure might rise because some of the 8,400 claims are
class actions covering a number of individuals -- and further claims may yet
be filed.
Hollis Haltom, the 82-year-old Texan who brought the case against Bayer in
Corpus Christi, claimed $560 million.
Haltom, who developed rhabdomyolysis after taking Baycol, claimed Bayer was
negligent in the way it sold the drug. But the 12-member jury determined
that Baycol's design and marketing instructions were not defective.
"We believe it is a vindication of Bayer and its position all through this
litigation that it acted responsibly when developing and marketing the drug,
and finally with its decision to pull Baycol from the market," said Philip
Beck, Bayer's lead attorney.
Next on the horizon for Bayer is a case in Minnesota, where plaintiffs'
lawyers are seeking class action status for several thousand patients who
claim they were injured by Baycol.